Episode Twenty Five | Bake-Off

An overhead shot of someone making cookies.

Listen to Episode 25:

The head of purchasing and IT at America’s largest fortune cookie supplier takes on a new role as head fortune cookie writer. A baker with Down syndrome has to break the law to lead an independent life and career. This week, two stories of remarkable people in who fight the odds to pursue their passions.

Illustration by Ping Zhu

Building a business when no one will hire you When employers saw only her disability, one cookie-baking entrepreneur saw an opportunity

An extended audio version of this story can be heard on Episode 25 of Work in Progress, Slack’s podcast about the meaning and identity we find in work.

Collette Divitto says the hardest thing about having Down syndrome is having her family tell her what she can and cannot do. But the 26-year-old cookie-baking entrepreneur has her family’s full support in Collettey’s Cookies, her Boston-based business that’s become a viral success story.

Growing up in Connecticut, Divitto depended on her family for support, like any other teen. After graduating from high school, she was adamant about attending a traditional college just like her siblings.

She headed to South Carolina, enrolling in Clemson University’s ClemsonLIFE, a unique program for students with disabilities who need support but are also seeking a conventional college campus experience.

“Living independently can be a really hard thing at first,” Divitto says of her collegiate experience. “I got nervous and scared to live away from home and my family.”

Pretty soon, Divitto settled in, and her social life took off. She was far more preoccupied with campus activities than taking check-in calls from family members. “The first time she hung up on me, I was overjoyed!” says her mother, Rosemary Alfredo, of her daughter’s increased self-reliance.

When she wasn’t making new friends, Divitto perfected the basics of independent living: paying bills, learning to cook, and keeping her apartment clean.

Coming home was a shock, though. Society didn’t see Divitto the same way she understood her own growing independence. Even with a college degree in hand and volunteer positions on her resume, she struggled to find a job. No one would hire her due to her disability.

While searching for gainful employment, Divitto returned to a hobby that had sustained her during a similarly dispiriting stretch of her teenage years: baking cookies from scratch. Supported by her family, she started a small-scale enterprise, selling her cookies at local establishments and garnering a tremendous response from the community.

The path forward became obvious pretty quickly. If Divitto could only scale up her cookie business, she wouldn’t need to find an employer. She could be her own boss.

Nearby Boston offered more opportunities to start a small business. But she was in a unique situation and couldn’t just pack up and move.

Collette bakes cookies in a kitchen wearing an apron with her name on it Collette Divitto bakes her signature Amazing Cookie at a production facility in Boston

When Divitto became an adult, her parents transferred guardianship to the state of Connecticut. It’s a common arrangement for adults with Down syndrome, but in Collette’s case, it meant her mother couldn’t make decisions on her behalf or help her relocate without permission.

Even more problematic, Collette’s father didn’t want her to move. When her parents couldn’t agree, the judge decided Divitto should live in a group home with other disabled adults.

It could’ve been a tremendous blow to Divitto’s dreams of self-sufficient life in the big city. “If Collette told me she wanted to live in the group home in Connecticut and work at McDonald’s, if that’s what’s going to make her happy, that’s what she’d be doing,” Alfredo says.

Since that wasn’t her enterprising daughter’s dream, they packed up and headed for Beantown anyway.

It turned out to be a smart move. Connecticut issued a warrant to get her back, but the family was free to settle in Boston when the State of Massachusetts refused to turn in Divitto.

“All I want for myself is to live in Boston, to have my own apartment with a roommate,” Divitto says.

Now, that’s exactly what she has — plus a growing business to boot. In December 2016, CBS Boston aired a segment about her cookies before the holidays. The story went viral, and now Divitto’s family continues to support what is becoming a big business, producing 1,000 handmade cookies every day. Even Collette’s sister, Blake, helps with the marketing.

The main attraction, Collettey’s Amazing Cookie, lives up to its name and needs little in the way of extra publicity. “It is amazing because of the chocolate chips and cinnamon,” Divitto explains.

Colleen overseas cookie packaging. Collette Divitto, with employees Emily and Marissa, oversees packaging of cookies bound for the Oscars

It may be hard to listen to her family sometimes, but like any other family-run small business, Divitto’s mom and sister are integral to her success.

“With my mom, she’s not just my mom,” Divitto says. “She is a part of my company — my business partner who does all the money stuff, like how much a cookie costs, and she had to bring the boxes of cookies to the post office.”

Most importantly, Divitto says other people like her shouldn’t give up on their dreams. “Try focusing on your abilities, not your disabilities.”

Work in Progress story produced by Mio Adilman.

May we recommend...

Christian Ziebarth at the Naugles test kitchen. SlackHQ.com

Recreating a secret sauce With no restaurant experience, one entrepreneur is determined to revive a defunct but beloved chain

Most people have fond nostalgia for the chain restaurants of their childhood, but Christian Ziebarth found his calling in those affectionate memories. The web developer and early food blogger, who had no actual restaurant business experience, made it his unlikely mission to reopen Naugles, a beloved Mexican food chain that closed in 1995…

Jean in front of the spaceship Discovery. SlackHQ.com

Seamstress to the (literal) stars How Jean Wright worked for three decades to land her dream job of sewing for NASA

One summer evening in July of 1969, 13-year-old Jean Wright stepped outside her house and stared up at the night sky. The moon above Flint, Michigan glowed as brightly as ever that night, but Wright looked at it differently. Moments earlier she had watched Neil Armstrong on TV as he took his first historic steps on its barren surface, and suddenly the dark sky brimmed with possibility…